.ctl-bullets-container { display: block; position: fixed; right: 0; height: 100%; z-index: 1049; font-weight: normal; height: 70vh; overflow-x: hidden; overflow-y: auto; margin: 15vh auto; }
Skip to content

Efficient Heating: Replacing boilers with Heat Pumps for Energy Savings and Comfort

Heat pump vs boiler:

When it comes to replacing boiler with heat pump, it is recommended to seek the assistance of a professional. Heat pumps have become increasingly popular as a replacement option for outdated heating systems. They offer a highly efficient and effective way to heat your home, surpassing the traditional method of heating and circulating water within the system. Despite uncertainties surrounding the process of replacing an old gas boiler with a heat pump, the conversion itself is straightforward and entails only a few steps. In this blog post, we will explore the process of replacing a gas boiler with a heat pump and shed light on the advantages it brings.


Why would you choose to replace the boiler with a heat pump? Here are some of the benefits:

Advantages of boilers

  1. Installing a new boiler is generally less expensive than installing a heat pump, assuming your radiators and distribution pipes are in good condition.
  2. Boilers are a well-established technology that many homeowners are familiar with.
  3. Some individuals prefer the distinct feel of radiant heat through a radiator.
  4. A boiler can also serve as a source of hot water, eliminating the need for an additional external water heater.
  5. Boilers offer versatility in fuel sources, including electricity, gas, or oil.
  6. With proper care, boilers can last for a long time, often exceeding 15 years.
  7. However, there are several significant drawbacks to consider:


Disadvantages of boilers

  1. Boilers are less efficient than heat pumps, resulting in higher ongoing energy consumption.
  2. There is a risk of fire and explosion associated with boilers, although such incidents are relatively rare.
  3. Boilers can be slow to change the temperature in your house after adjusting the thermostat.
  4. Heating your home with a boiler can lead to uneven distribution of heat.
  5. Depending on the fuel used, boilers can contribute to indoor air quality issues.
  6. Boilers can produce considerable noise, particularly if there is a malfunction.
  7. Boiler technology is outdated, having been around for over 200 years, and repairs can be costly.
  8. The average cost of replacing a boiler is approximately $8,000, and the expenses can rise further if you need to replace radiators in your home. This cost only covers the replacement of the system and does not include air conditioning.
  9. An older boiler or one with undetected faults or leaks can cause water damage to your house.
  10. Boilers are dependent on the condition of distribution pipes and radiators, which, if in poor condition, can result in energy waste and an uncomfortable living environment.
  11. Boilers operate as a separate system, requiring the purchase and maintenance of a separate HVAC appliance if you desire air conditioning.


In summary, boilers are an older technology that can adequately provide heat when well-maintained. However, they are not as efficient as modern alternatives and come with certain risks.

heat pump installation


There are numerous advantages to choosing whether to use the heat pump or boiler system. Here are a few:


Advantages of cold climate heat pumps

  1. Heat pumps are significantly more energy-efficient than boilers, resulting in a substantial reduction of energy waste.
  2. Heat pumps serve as all-in-one systems, providing heating, cooling, air filtration, and dehumidification.
  3. Heat pumps offer clean and fresh air without any odors or the risk of carbon monoxide poisoning.
  4. Heat pumps solely rely on electricity, eliminating the need for gas or oil delivery.
  5. They operate quietly, often going unnoticed while running.
  6. Heat pumps don’t require ductwork and are low maintenance, avoiding the need to maintain a radiator and steam pipe system or underfloor heating.
  7. Mini-split heat pumps allow for individual temperature control in each room, minimizing thermostat disagreements.
  8. Many individuals appreciate the constant flow of fresh and warm air that heat pumps provide.
  9. Heat pumps operate safely without any risk of explosion.
  10. Essentially, heat pumps represent a remarkable HVAC technology, akin to the Tesla of the industry. However, they do have a few drawbacks.


Disadvantages of cold climate heat pumps

  1. If your boiler also provides hot water, you may need a separate water heater, although heat pump water heaters offer highly efficient alternatives.
  2. In extremely cold climates where temperatures regularly drop below -13 degrees Fahrenheit, you might need to supplement your heat pump with backup electric heat or retain your old boiler. Such installations, known as “dual-fuel heat pump packages,” are more efficient than relying solely on traditional boiler heating. You can check the temperature at which a heat pump stops working here.
  3. While heat pumps can be more cost-effective to operate and maintain in the long run due to their higher efficiency, they are generally more expensive to install. In fact, the installation cost of a heat pump is similar to installing a furnace and an air conditioning system simultaneously.
  4. It’s important to note that if your home qualifies, you may be eligible to have your heat pump installed at no upfront cost.


Before deciding to replace your old gas boiler with a heat pump, there are several factors you should consider:


  1. Assess your existing boiler setup: Determine the type of boiler you currently have (electric or gas), its heating capacity, and its size. This information will help you select the appropriate size, type, and location for the new heat pump. Additionally, ensure that the old boiler can be removed without causing any damage to your home’s walls or ceiling. If not, you may need to choose a new unit that can fit through the same opening.
  2. Consider your home’s size and heating requirements: Take into account the size of your home and its specific heating needs. A heat pump that is too large may struggle to cool the house efficiently, while one that is too small may only provide heating without cooling capabilities. It’s important to find the right balance to optimize energy efficiency and comfort.
  3. Calculate the cost and potential savings: Determine the cost of replacing your gas boiler with a heat pump by considering factors such as the type and age of your current boiler, as well as its operating expenses. Consult with your gas company for estimates. Next, evaluate the potential savings on your electricity bill by comparing your current energy usage with the projected usage if you switch to an electric heat pump. This analysis will help you understand the financial implications and potential benefits of the switch.
  4. Compare options and make an informed decision: Once you have gathered all the necessary information, compare the costs, savings, and performance of both the gas boiler and heat pump options. Consider your specific circumstances, budget, and long-term goals to determine which choice is the most suitable for your needs.


By carefully considering these factors, you can make an informed decision about whether replacing your old gas boiler with a heat pump is the right choice for your home.

Air source heat pump installation


When replacing your gas boiler with a heat pump, there are various options to consider based on your specific needs. One cost-effective choice is a heat pump water heater, also known as a split heat and hot water heater. These systems are particularly suitable for homes located in moderate climates and aim to reduce energy expenses.


Heat pump water heaters operate by utilizing a condenser coil to extract heat from the surrounding air and transfer it into the home’s cooling system. This enables independent operation of the air conditioner and furnace, leading to reduced electricity bills and environmental benefits. Moreover, these systems feature an efficient compressor that ensures instant delivery of warm water whenever required. Unlike other systems that store warm water in a tank until it reaches the desired temperature for showers or baths, heat pump water heaters provide on-demand hot water.


Furthermore, opting for such systems not only saves on heating costs but also facilitates year-round heating for swimming pools. They eliminate the need for separate heating systems for hot water and other cold applications within the house, providing a convenient and efficient solution.


Considering these advantages, a heat pump water heater is a viable option to replace your gas boiler, especially if you reside in a non-cold climate and aim to lower energy bills while enjoying the benefits of a versatile hot water supply.


tags: {heat pump vs gas boiler air to water heat pump boiler air to water heat pump boiler heat pump boiler replacement cost air source heat pump boiler heat pump boiler systems heat pump hydronic boiler replace oil boiler with heat pump replacing boiler with heat pump heat pump boiler cost boiler heat pump cost heat pump boiler how does it work cost to replace gas boiler with heat pump heat pump hot water boiler heat pump water boiler ground source heat pump boiler heat pump electric boiler pump for boiler heater residential heat pump boiler electric heat pump boiler heat pump vs boiler cost high temperature heat pump boiler heat pump vs oil boiler calculator hybrid boiler and heat pump boiler heat pump system boiler and heat pump }</p>

Related posts

Related heat pump products

Get Quote